Muslims have been in this country for close to 50 years, but unfortunately
the image most closely associated with Islam in people’s minds is the
Bali bombings and September 11.
It is therefore understandable that many Australians hold misgivings and concerns
about Muslims.
However, just as the Bali bombers justified their actions with exaggerated claims
of Western political injustice and immorality, many of those who hold anti-Muslim
views in the West base them upon a distorted view of Islam and the Muslim community.
Although the September 11 hijackers and Bali bombers were not American Muslims,
there exists a distrust of Muslim minorities in the West.
This has been exacerbated by the occasional media reference to Australian Muslims
with links to, or sympathies for, bin Laden.
The response of most Muslim spokesmen has been sophistry or denial. However,
it is true that many Australian Muslims sympathise with bin Laden.
Yet those Muslim who hold sympathies for him do so not because they believe
he carried out the repulsive attacks of September 11, but rather because they
believe he did not; that the case against bin Laden has yet to be conclusively
proven. It’s an important distinction.
Indeed, Muslim support for jihad has been misconstrued by a public discourse
that uses the term as a synonym for violent terror campaigns against civilians.
However, as one Muslim speaker recently quipped, terrorism is to jihad as adultery
is to marriage.
Jihad, as understood by almost every Muslim, amount to the belief that man has
a natural right to defend himself and his interests from attack.
It is a concept that, if adequately explained, most Australians would accept.
In that sense, the jihads being fought by Muslims today are not wars to expand
the borders of the Islamic world. Chechens don’t desire to expand their
borders into Russia, and Palestinians do not aspire to a Greater Palestine that
extends from the Nile to the Euphrates.
Rather, these are simply battles for self-determination: the right of the people
to choose no only those who rule them but also the systems by which they are
ruled.
The demand for an increased political role for Islam in Muslim societies is
reflective of the global Islamic revival. Even in the West, increasing numbers
of mostly young Muslim men and women are turning to Islam as the answer to the
many uncertainties and issues we face in the modern world.
In Melbourne, lectures organised by ostensibly fundamentalist, yet non-extremist
organisations such as the nation Islamic Information and Services Network of
Australasia (IISNA) comfortably draw more than 1000 people.
The distinction between Islamic fundamentalism and Muslim extremism has been
collapsed, with every fundamentalist seen as a wide-eyed anti-Western fanatic.
However, terrorism is not born out of a fundamentalist interpretation of one’s
faith, but rather from a lax and ignorant interpretation of the fundamentals.
It is based on the idea that just causes can be furthered by unjust means.
The most vociferous exponents of moderation and opponents of terrorism in the
Muslim world have been the fundamentalists themselves.
The previous Mufti of Saudi Arabia, Sheik Ibn Baz, condemned all attacks on
civilians and the spreading of civil strife in the name of jihad.
This condemnation came years before September 11 when such fatwas became fashionable.
His successor has condemned September 11 and called for the perpetrators of
the Riyadh bombings to be brought to justice.
Likewise, here in Australia, Islamic fundamentalist groups and scholars have
spoken widely and loudly opposing terror and in favouring peaceful co-existence
between Muslim and non-Muslim worlds.
Just as Muslims must recognise that the West is more than alcohol, pornography
and Zionism, non-Muslims must recognise that Islam is about more than beards,
burqas and bombs.
The prevailing myths about Islam and the Muslims must be abandoned in favour
of a more dispassionate and nuanced understanding.
Only when we have this understanding can we have trust, and it is only on a
foundation of trust that true social cohesion can be built.
abutler@muslimaffairs.com.au
Amir Butler is executive director of the Australian Muslim Public Affairs Committee.